High-frequency trading (HFT) has transformed the financial landscape, shifting power from human traders to algorithms and supercomputers. As Michael Lewis, author of Flash Boys, once noted: "People are no longer accountable for what happens in the market, because computers are making all the decisions."
In the U.S., over half of all stock trades are now executed not by people, but by high-speed computer systems capable of placing millions of orders daily—often gaining a competitive edge measured in milliseconds. These automated systems allow major players like investment banks and hedge funds to leverage algorithms and real-time data to generate profits through volume rather than large margins per trade.
Yet, the golden era of HFT appears to be fading. By 2018, profits from high-frequency trading had plummeted nearly 86% compared to their peak a decade earlier. With shrinking returns and rising costs, the industry is undergoing consolidation as firms seek survival strategies in an increasingly competitive environment.
Let’s explore what high-frequency trading is, how it works, and why its dominance is waning.
Understanding High-Frequency Trading
High-frequency trading refers to the use of advanced technology—particularly algorithmic systems—to execute a vast number of orders at extremely high speeds. Large institutions such as hedge funds and proprietary trading firms rely on automated platforms that scan multiple markets simultaneously, identifying fleeting opportunities for profit.
When properly designed, these algorithms give firms a crucial edge. Powerful computing infrastructure can detect emerging trends across global markets and act on them before human traders even notice.
Key characteristics commonly associated with high-frequency trading include:
- Extremely high order volume
- Rapid order cancellation
- Ultra-short holding periods (often seconds or less)
- No end-of-day positions (all trades closed within the same session)
- Minimal profit per trade
- Use of direct data feeds and proximity hosting services
- Proprietary trading (trading for the firm’s own account, not clients)
These traits enable HFT firms to capitalize on tiny price discrepancies across exchanges—a strategy known as arbitrage—while contributing significant liquidity to financial markets.
👉 Discover how algorithmic trading strategies are shaping modern finance today.
Why Does High-Frequency Trading Exist?
Despite criticism, HFT persists because it serves a functional role in modern markets: liquidity provision. By flooding the market with buy and sell orders, HFT systems help narrow bid-ask spreads and ensure smoother price discovery.
This benefits all market participants by reducing transaction costs. In return, HFT firms earn small profits from the spread—the difference between the buying and selling price of an asset—and often receive rebates from exchanges for providing liquidity.
Their business model hinges on scale: individual trades yield fractions of a cent, so profitability depends entirely on executing millions of transactions daily. The more active the market, the more opportunities arise.
Moreover, exchanges incentivize HFT activity by offering lower fees or even payments (rebates) to those who add liquidity, making the ecosystem mutually reinforcing—though not without controversy.
The Role of Spreads and Market Liquidity
Spreads and liquidity are deeply interconnected. Highly liquid markets—like forex, which sees over $5 trillion traded daily—typically feature tight spreads due to constant buying and selling pressure.
In such environments, traders must execute large volumes to accumulate meaningful gains. This is where leverage becomes essential. Without it, small price movements would result in negligible returns. Leverage allows traders to amplify exposure, turning micro-movements into profitable outcomes—especially in fast-moving, high-volume markets where HFT thrives.
Conversely, less liquid markets suffer from wider spreads, increasing transaction costs and reducing efficiency. HFT helps mitigate this imbalance by injecting continuous order flow, though its presence is most pronounced in mature, deep markets like U.S. equities.
Is High-Frequency Trading Ethical?
The rise of HFT has sparked debate over fairness and market integrity. Critics argue that giving technologically advanced firms nanosecond advantages undermines equal access—a concern amplified by practices like latency arbitrage, where HFT firms exploit speed differences between exchanges.
Retail investors, in particular, face an uphill battle against algorithmic systems that process information and execute trades far beyond human capability. While HFT adds liquidity, some question whether this service is reliable during volatile periods, noting that many HFT firms withdraw during market stress—precisely when liquidity is most needed.
Pros and Cons of High-Frequency Trading
Advantages:
- Increases market liquidity
- Reduces bid-ask spreads
- Enhances price efficiency
- Enables faster trade execution
Disadvantages:
- Favors well-capitalized institutions
- May destabilize markets (e.g., "flash crashes")
- Raises ethical concerns about fairness
- Contributes to arms race in speed technology
How Big Is the High-Frequency Trading Market?
The U.S. remains the epicenter of HFT activity. Since 2008, high-frequency trading has accounted for at least 50% of total equity market volume, peaking at 60% in 2009. Although activity dipped post-financial crisis, it rebounded after 2016.
In Europe, HFT adoption lagged behind by several years. It emerged around 2006—by which time it already represented nearly 25% of U.S. trading volume. European HFT peaked in 2010, one year after the U.S., and has since followed a similar trajectory.
Despite regional differences, both markets reflect broader trends: increased automation, tighter margins, and growing regulatory scrutiny.
Why Are HFT Profits Declining?
According to TABB Group estimates, U.S. high-frequency trading profits collapsed from $7.2 billion in 2009 to under $1 billion by 2017—a staggering 86% drop. Several interrelated factors explain this decline:
- Intensifying Competition: As more firms adopt similar strategies, arbitrage opportunities vanish quickly.
- Rising Costs: Infrastructure expenses—including co-location services (hosting servers near exchange data centers)—have surged.
- Reduced Market Volatility: Lower volatility means fewer price discrepancies to exploit.
- Data Cost Inflation: Exchanges charge premium prices for real-time data feeds, cutting into margins.
Vikas Shah, an investment banker at Rosenblatt Securities, emphasized that HFT success depends on two variables: trading volume and market volatility. When both decline, profitability suffers.
👉 Explore cutting-edge trading technologies reshaping financial markets in 2025.
The Rise of Dark Pools
As data costs rise and public market advantages erode, dark pools—private trading venues where large orders are executed anonymously—have gained traction.
Dark pools allow institutional investors to trade large blocks without revealing their intentions to the broader market. This shields them from front-running by HFT algorithms that monitor public order books.
While proponents argue dark pools reduce market impact for big trades, critics claim they undermine transparency and create unequal access. Their growth correlates with declining HFT activity on public exchanges—suggesting a shift in where liquidity resides.
Additionally, past incidents like the 2010 "Flash Crash," partly attributed to HFT behavior, have driven demand for alternative execution methods perceived as more stable.
Industry Consolidation Among HFT Firms
Faced with shrinking returns and escalating costs, many HFT firms are merging or being acquired. Notable examples include:
- Virtu Financial’s $1.4 billion acquisition of KCG Holdings in 2018
- DRW Holdings’ purchase of RGM Advisors
- Hudson River Trading’s acquisition of Sun Trading
These consolidations reflect a broader trend: only the largest, most efficient players can sustain the massive investments required for speed and data access.
Evolving Regulation of High-Frequency Trading
Regulatory frameworks like the U.S.’s Reg NMS (National Market System) were intended to promote fairness but have inadvertently favored high-speed traders. By requiring orders to be filled at the best available price across exchanges, Reg NMS enables HFT firms to detect price changes on one exchange and trade ahead on others—an advantage critics call "legal front-running."
Similarly, Europe’s MiFID II introduced rules requiring HFT firms to register with regulators and maintain detailed records. However, defining HFT remains challenging due to inconsistent standards across jurisdictions.
Experts agree: while current regulations curb abuse, more comprehensive oversight may be necessary to ensure market equity.
👉 Learn how regulatory developments are influencing algorithmic trading innovation.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is high-frequency trading in simple terms?
A: High-frequency trading uses powerful computers and algorithms to execute thousands or millions of trades per second, profiting from tiny price changes.
Q: Is high-frequency trading still profitable?
A: While still operational, profitability has sharply declined due to increased competition, higher costs, and reduced volatility.
Q: Do high-frequency traders manipulate the market?
A: While not inherently manipulative, certain HFT practices—like quote stuffing or latency arbitrage—have raised ethical and regulatory concerns.
Q: Can retail traders compete with high-frequency trading?
A: Direct competition is nearly impossible due to technological disparities. However, retail traders benefit indirectly through tighter spreads and improved liquidity.
Q: How do dark pools affect high-frequency trading?
A: Dark pools reduce visibility into large trades, limiting HFT’s ability to exploit public order flow data—leading some to shift focus or exit public markets.
Q: What role does latency play in HFT?
A: Latency—the delay in data transmission—is critical. Even microseconds matter; firms invest heavily in co-location and fiber-optic networks to minimize it.
Core Keywords: high-frequency trading, algorithmic trading, market liquidity, bid-ask spread, dark pools, trading volatility, co-location services, Reg NMS